General Homsar General Homsar

Good Idea/Bad Idea: The Forum Game

Good Idea/Bad Idea: The Forum Game

Life lessons will be learned!

The rules here are simple: Someone posts a good idea, then someone else posts a bad idea. The catch? The bad idea must be a messed-up, corrupted version of the good idea.

For Example:

Good Idea: getting a front-row seat at a boxing match

Bad Idea: Getting an in-ring seat at a boxing match.

Have fun!

2,331,122 views 1,363 replies
Reply #1301 Top

Bad Idea: purging the clean.

 

Good Idea: just bombarding the alien planets and getting it over with rather than wasting the lives of space marines.

Reply #1302 Top

Quoting numerarius5988am, reply 1301
Bad Idea: purging the clean.

 

Good Idea: just bombarding the alien planets and getting it over with rather than wasting the lives of space marines.

Bad Idea: bombarding a planet with LOTS of valuable materials. Also, bombarding a planet YOU own that has been invaded.

Good Idea: Death From Above.

Reply #1303 Top

Bad Idea: that isn't your fighter craft above!

 

Good Idea: needs more cowbell.

 

 

Reply #1304 Top

Quoting numerarius5988am, reply 1303
Bad Idea: that isn't your fighter craft above!

 

Good Idea: needs more cowbell.

 

 


Bad Idea: posting Star Trek *RAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAGE*

Good Idea: Warhammer 40,000. Yeah, we may have tanks that belong in the 1st World War. But we can tell physics to screw off anytime we want, and have it really happen.

Reply #1305 Top

Bad Idea: using weapons from the Punic War to fight alien hoards.

 

Good Idea: using weapons from the second world war, specifically the one first tested at Trinity NM in 1945, against the alien hoard.

Reply #1306 Top

Quoting numerarius5988am, reply 1305
Bad Idea: using weapons from the Punic War to fight alien hoards.

 

Good Idea: using weapons from the second world war, specifically the one first tested at Trinity NM in 1945, against the alien hoard.

Bad Idea: using WWII era weaponry to fight aliens

Good Idea: using weapons that completely ignore the laws of physics to fight said aliens.

Reply #1307 Top

Bad Idea: using weapons which don't work against a threat which can easily kill by brute force alone.

 

Good Idea: neutron bombs.

Reply #1308 Top

Quoting numerarius5988am, reply 1307
Bad Idea: using weapons which don't work against a threat which can easily kill by brute force alone.

 

Good Idea: neutron bombs.

Bad Idea: using C4 as a missile warhead in SPAAACE!

Good Idea: kinetic rounds with bursting charges. IN SPAAACE!

Reply #1309 Top

Bad Idea: kinetic rounds traveling with zero relative velocity with respect to the target vessel. In space!

 

Good Idea: incorporating the idea of a capital ship carrier which can instantly transport to any explored gravity well (as per the book Star Strike by Ian Douglas) into SoaSE. Along with having Marine Boarding Craft capable of hijacking enemy ships and orbital platforms.

Reply #1310 Top

Quoting numerarius5988am, reply 1309
Bad Idea: kinetic rounds traveling with zero relative velocity with respect to the target vessel. In space!

 

Good Idea: incorporating the idea of a capital ship carrier which can instantly transport to any explored gravity well (as per the book Star Strike by Ian Douglas) into SoaSE. Along with having Marine Boarding Craft capable of hijacking enemy ships and orbital platforms.

Bad Idea: trying your Good Idea. Mostly because I've tried to do anywhere-to-anywhere jump drives, and they failed spectacularly.

Good Idea: FIGHTING MEN OF THE DRAGOONS, CHAAAARGE!!

2nd Bad Idea: playing paintball, with only a T-shirt, shorts, and eye-protection.

2nd Good Idea: CHAAARGE!!

Reply #1311 Top

Bad idea: having sex with the guy who posted above me

Good Idea: using thermite and a blowtorch to grill my steak

Reply #1312 Top

Quoting shark1669, reply 1311
Bad idea: having sex with the guy who posted above me

Good Idea: using thermite and a blowtorch to grill my steak

Bad Idea: necro'ing a thread.

Bad Idea: posting ideas that have to do with sexual relations. It's in very poor taste.

Bad Idea: using thermite, in any way, shape, or form, on food.

Good Idea: can't think of one ATM.

Reply #1313 Top

Bad Idea: not thinking and forgetting the condom in your back pocket... which is probably  how most of us were born anyway, so go right ahead. :grin:

Good Idea: Karma to the Forum King!

Xer0 \^/

Reply #1314 Top

Quoting Xer07, reply 1313
Bad Idea: not thinking and forgetting the condom in your back pocket... which is probably  how most of us were born anyway, so go right ahead.

Good Idea: Karma to the Forum King!

Xer0 \^/

BAD IDEA: talking about condoms. Really now, are we that crude?

GOOD IDEA: XER07 MUST POST IN THE REAL CHATROOM THREAD NAO.

Reply #1315 Top

Bad Idea: The one Morpheas made? Eh, I'll check it out.

Good Idea: Talking about condoms. European teenagers have 3x as much sex as Americans, but have 1/2 the rate of pregnancy. The cause? Condoms.

Xer0 \^/

Reply #1316 Top

Quoting Xer07, reply 1315
Bad Idea: The one Morpheas made? Eh, I'll check it out.

Good Idea: Talking about condoms. European teenagers have 3x as much sex as Americans, but have 1/2 the rate of pregnancy. The cause? Condoms.

Xer0 \^/

Bad Idea: premarital sex. Seriously, abstinence is the only 100% effective method of birth control.

Good Idea: LAZ0RS!!!

Reply #1317 Top

Thanks for telling me that premarital sex was a bad idea, Whiskey. Glad to know we're on the same page. :bebi:

Bad Idea: Not watching the Lazer Collection.

Good Idea: Watching the Lazer Collection.

Xer0 \^/

Reply #1318 Top

Quoting Xer07, reply 1317
Thanks for telling me that premarital sex was a bad idea, Whiskey. Glad to know we're on the same page.

Bad Idea: Not watching the Lazer Collection.

Good Idea: Watching the Lazer Collection.

Xer0 \^/

Bad Idea: Star Trek ethics. Seriously, the Prime Directive is so immoral that it's mind-bogglingly stupid how they obey it.

Good Idea: intervention in MAD scenarios between lesser powers. Prevention of said MAD is morally right, contrary to what Gene Rodenberry and his ST:The Next Generation series would have us believe.

Reply #1319 Top

Bad Idea: Um, wut?

Good Idea: Buying Until We Have Faces by R3D, which comes out Feb. 1st

Xer0 \^/

Reply #1320 Top

Quoting Whiskey144, reply 1316
Bad Idea: premarital sex. Seriously, abstinence is the only 100% effective method of birth control.

Darth Vader and Jesus. Search for the demotivationals.

Bad idea: using multiple forums with the same attitude.

Reply #1321 Top

Quoting Xer07, reply 1319
Bad Idea: Um, wut?

Good Idea: Buying Until We Have Faces by R3D, which comes out Feb. 1st

Xer0 \^/

Bad Idea: it's a hangup I've gotten with Star Trek. The mind-bogglingly stupid things the writers (and Gene Rodenberry) have that they put into the later ST series (i.e., past the days of Kirk), is, well, mind-boggling.

Good Idea: no. I will not buy that album. I am more interested in other things. And have never heard of 'R3D'.

Quoting IrationalFear, reply 1320
Darth Vader and Jesus. Search for the demotivationals.

Bad idea: using multiple forums with the same attitude.

Okay, I'll just point out that Darth Vader is a fictional character, and probably was explained away using 'midichlorian' technobabble, while Jesus was a case of divine intervention.

And midichlorians aren't real, and God only did the whole divine conception thing once. He's not going to do that again.

Reply #1322 Top

Good Idea: Buying that album. Seriously.

Bad Idea: Ever notice that "God" needed machines to move around the earth? :P

Xer0 \^/

Reply #1323 Top

Good Idea: Machines to move around the earth.

Bad Idea: Assuming God needs anything from earth.... :-"

Reply #1324 Top

Bad Idea: Machines ruling the earth.

Good Idea: Ever notice that virtually EVERY religion has their god(s) moving to/from the stars in some sort of vehicle?

Xer0 \^/

Reply #1325 Top

Quoting Xer07, reply 1322
Good Idea: Buying that album. Seriously.

Bad Idea: Ever notice that "God" needed machines to move around the earth?

Xer0 \^/

Bad Idea: buying the album.

On a side note, God doesn't, and never will need anything to move around anywhere. He's omnipresent, omniscient, and omnipotent.

He needs to move around why?

Quoting SivCorp, reply 1323
Good Idea: Machines to move around the earth.

Bad Idea: Assuming God needs anything from earth....

Machines to move around the Earth, I agree.

God doesn't need anything from Earth; He wants something from it, namely, the salvation of humanity.

Quoting Xer07, reply 1324
Bad Idea: Machines ruling the earth.

Good Idea: Ever notice that virtually EVERY religion has their god(s) moving to/from the stars in some sort of vehicle?

Xer0 \^/

Machines ruling Earth: BAD.

Catholicism doesn't, Protestantism doesn't. I don't think that virtually every religion has that. I know that the God of the Bible doesn't.

He can walk around, but He doesn't need to.

 

Good Idea: genetic&bioengineering, cybernetic enhancement, and brain-computer neural interfaces.

It's a WIN-WIN.