Notice: Pending mods now under review!

from GalCiv2 Forums
Mavx and myself have finally been granted library control access, so the backlog of pending mods will now be processed through as we can get to them. It seems some people have complained about not getting any notice about rejections, so just to be safe I'll try to post the mods here that get approved/rejected.

For the record, about the only things that *should* get rejected are obscene or blatant copyright/IP infringement (i.e., photgraphs of actors, soundtracks, video clips, etc.). If it is anything you created yourself or got from public domain/open source sources, it should be fine.

Also, please do not include unchanged graphics, etc, that are arleady in GC2 in your mods (such is just extra downloading for nothing, and potentially makes GC2 content available to those who have not bought the game). In most cases you can simply reference the existing files and it'll work the same.
modding
512,134 views 248 replies
Reply #1 from GalCiv2 Forums Top
To make things easier on both of us i suggest posting the name of the mod we are testing first and then editing the post later to say whether or not it has been approved/rejected. That will stop us from testing the same mod twice.



To extend on DK's post above, we will be rejecting instantly any mods (ie logo's & portraits) that obviously have copyrighted materials in them. To facilitate us in our job please add the link you got the image from if it was from a public domain source. If you can prove its not a breach of copyright we will allow the mod!
Reply #2 from GalCiv2 Forums Top
Rav's Babylon 5 Mod 0.2 and YorCylon Omega Shipyard Pack have been approved.
Sins of a Solar Empire II
Reply #3 from GalCiv2 Forums Top
FYI, the following mods are already listed as denied (by StarDock, not us):

KH Imperium Race 6/22/2006
Full Metal Alchemist Mod 6/22/2006
Terminator Race Pics 5/27/2006
Improved Planetary Improvements 5/16/2006
Improved Planetary Improvements 5/16/2006
Improved Planetary Improvements 4/23/2006
united planets of America 4/21/2006
XSeries 1st set 4/15/2006
Battlestar Galactica Leader Portraits 4/7/2006
Battlestar Galactica Leader Portraits 4/6/2006
more farscape races 3/30/2006
Borg Cube 3/17/2006
Flagship Design 3/17/2006
Basic Romulan Portrait 3/14/2006
Stargate Protrait 3/11/2006
Romulan Portrait 3/11/2006
Portrait Pack - Final Fantasy: The Spirits Within 3/11/2006
Federation Protrait 3/11/2006
Zim Custom Portraits! 3/9/2006
Reply #4 from GalCiv2 Forums Top
Far be it from me to complain, given that I love the mod and am currently playing it, but how does one reconcile the approved B5 mod with the "No CopyVio" policy?
Reply #5 from GalCiv2 Forums Top
Well seen as how my moderation powers have now been stripped as the people at Stardock did not like my post i guess its down to you DK.
Its a pity it had to come down to the post but seen as no one was responding to *off line* requests for fixes i felt something had to be done. if the loss of my moderating abilities is the result of getting the issues fixed then i have served my purpose here.

Enjoy the new fixed site!
Reply #6 from GalCiv2 Forums Top
I was wondering the same thing myself. (in response to Ray Radlein's post)

How can we tell if something we find browsing the internet is public domain or not?
Reply #7 from GalCiv2 Forums Top
Far be it from me to complain, given that I love the mod and am currently playing it, but how does one reconcile the approved B5 mod with the "No CopyVio" policy?


To my knowledge, the B5 models were either user created or obtained from user mod projects for other games. They were not, for example, stolen from the makers of B5 directly.
Reply #8 from GalCiv2 Forums Top
To save the moderators some trouble, please test your mods to make sure that they work before submitting them to the library.  Also, if your ships or other models are high poly, you may want to include a warning about that in your description.
Reply #9 from GalCiv2 Forums Top
there are alot of mods waiting in the library that for sure. my mod is witing since june 10
Reply #10 from GalCiv2 Forums Top
wow griffin, sorry about your mod powers, thats... wow, i just dont know, hopefully you get them back eventually, and thanks for this guys im glad someone is saying something about all the mods
Reply #11 from GalCiv2 Forums Top
It appears DG approved TechTree+, Ship Configuration Mod, and the MOO Race pack before he was demoted.

Seven unreviewd mods remain, I'm looking them over now.
Reply #12 from GalCiv2 Forums Top
Star Wars Ship Pack by BradenK approved.
Reply #13 from GalCiv2 Forums Top
Warhammer 40k mod by maddybadger: rejected.

This mod contains content taken directly from another mod by another author, with no permission mentioned. Also contains many images assumably scanned out of WH40k books or found online.
Reply #14 from GalCiv2 Forums Top
Turkey,Kosovo,Rheinland and texas all here by w00t u doing : approved
Reply #15 from GalCiv2 Forums Top
Narn Matte Space Logo by Star Dagger : approved
Reply #16 from GalCiv2 Forums Top
Doctor Who portrats by Entillzha : rejected

Readme says no infringement intended, but IP laywers don't tend to care much about such disclaimers. Contains images directly from Doctor Who.
Reply #17 from GalCiv2 Forums Top
Star Wars Hoth by MasterU : approved


Star Wars Jedi Temple by MasterU : rejected
Sorry, contains a photo directly from Star Wars.
Reply #19 from GalCiv2 Forums Top
contains a photo directly from Star Wars


if my mod of the jedi temple will be without the photo it will be approved?
Reply #20 from GalCiv2 Forums Top
I am making a mod that contains photos of poloticians that I got off of Google images. Will it be accepted?
Reply #21 from GalCiv2 Forums Top
if my mod of the jedi temple will be without the photo it will be approved?


That should be fine.

I am making a mod that contains photos of poloticians that I got off of Google images. Will it be accepted?


It would depend on where exactly you find the images. Most images from news outlets are copyrighted, and the ones on campaign websites might be. you might be able to find some on wikipedia that you can definitely use, as they list there whether the images are copyrighted, public domain, etc.
Reply #22 from GalCiv2 Forums Top
Macmatt, please remove the logos from the mod that are already included in the game. You should be able to leave the references intact and it'll work just the same since most of those are included in the base game and/or bonus pack. But please do not include reusable game content in your mods.

Let me know once you've updated it (you should be able to go the the My Mods page in the library and see/edit it) and I'll approve it.
Reply #23 from GalCiv2 Forums Top
Sorry about that, the images have now been removed.
Reply #24 from GalCiv2 Forums Top
ok I can understand why Stardock doesn't approve of some mods thats fine and all but perhaps someone who knows how to build a webpage with download area could have the unapproved mods there. Then we have the best of both worlds to coin a phrase. Just make it an Unofficial site for downloading. It would be great to have some form of site that has every mod thats been made available by the creators in once spot.

Then we can pick and choose and rate as we like and Stardock is off the hook. I would put up a site for this but alas I'm not really a web wizard.
Reply #25 from GalCiv2 Forums Top
I am working on creating such a site, starlost.  Stay tuned.