I know you are all waiting breadthlessly for the this announcement (tongue in cheek) but I did buy Elemental. I apologize for my excessive angst in coming to this decision.
However, just to hedge my bets, I also bought Age of Wonders Shadow Magic and Disciples II: Dark Phophecy Gold editon (has two mods in it). I tried each game out for about 4 hours apiece initially. Based on this very scientific testing procedure (tongue in cheek, again). Elemental ranked by far the highest followed by AOW: SM and then Disciples II. While all three seem to be good games Elemental stands far above the crowd.
I have not had any crashes on Elemental (1.11) thus far and I actually like the art style. I haven't done wvery well in Elemental either which seems to have the highest learning curve of the trio. It does have that submersive quality which deprives you of sleep, raises the ire of your spouse and is disappointing to your pet dalmatian (although I am obligated to a minimum amount of playtime with him regardless).
I have a couple of questions thus far.
1. Are there gold mines in the game? I have not been able to find any as yet.
2. Are there any other sources of metal beyond finding the stuff lying around? Are there metal mines or a blacksmith function for instance?
3. What's the best way to generate mana? I continually run out just about the time I have mastered all the 3rd level spells.