That's way more involved than I would ever want to be in something over a game. I have a life and if I wanted to do something like that, I'd join the local city council.
There's a lot of people that put a lot of hours into Eve (the same with many other MMORPG, like high level raiding guilds in WoW or things like that). That's their choice, they are free to do it. I'm sure there's people in these boards that would love to go to Stardock to chat with the Elemental team and try to give them solutions to the game issues.
In fact that seems like a downright miserable way to manage a community, encouraging the highly elite players to dominate the discussion and bleeding "game" politics into real life. With Elemental I'm reasonably confident that I can bring something up for discussion and have as good of a chance at having my response actually read as say, someone like RavenX, take that as you will.
I don't think you understand the CSM at all, and comparing it to Elemental is a mistake. Eve Online has forums where you can post your ideas and so on, exactly like here. The main forum for that is the "Features and Ideas Discussion" one.
http://www.eveonline.com/ingameboard.asp?a=channel&channelID=3523
You can check also the "Eve Gameplay Center" subforum is full of discussions about gameplay too. And that's not counting other forums like Scrapheap-Challenge and so on.
In EVE, I'd have to petition some random person who may not actually care about anything I have to say to maybe mention something I'm concerned about instead of something he (and if you see that picture, it's all men) thought was important to him and his guild/thing? That's the vibe I get and I don't like it.
Let my arguments stand on their own merit.
This doesn't make any sense. CSM players are 0.0 players or Empire players. These players in general have different needs, and the CSM has always some of those. But when a 0.0 player asks for something, is something that most 0.0 players agree is useful, not only his 0.0 corporation.
Also, take into account that Eve is massive, your suggestions may be great for you, but you may very well be ignorant of some parts of the game and don't realize your suggestion is a total failure because of other things, or don't see there are more important things to change or fix. Either way, feel free to argue in the forums new ideas, as there is a forum specially for bringing ideas to the CSM:
http://www.eveonline.com/ingameboard.asp?a=channel&channelID=752166
But as I posted earlier, the main problem is that the CSM is taken just as suggestions by CCP, nothing more, nothing less. It's a pitty, but I suppose that's all they can do.